ASTM E1169-02 - 10.10.2002
 
1. Scope

1.1 In studying a test method, it is necessary to consider the effect of environmental factors on the results obtained using the test method. If this effect is not considered, the results from the original developmental work on the test method may not be as accurate as expected.The purpose of a ruggedness test is to find the variables (experimental factors) that strongly influence the measurements provided by the test method, and to determine how closely these variables need to be controlled. Ruggedness tests do not determine the optimum conditions for the test method.

1.2 The experimental designs most often used in ruggedness testing are the so called "Plackett-Burman" designs (1). Other experimental designs also can be used. This guide, however, will restrict itself to Plackett-Burman designs with two levels per variable because these designs are particularly easy to use and are efficient in developing the information needed for improving test methods. The designs require the simultaneous change of the levels of all of the variables, and allow the determination of the separated effects of each of the variables on the measured results. In ruggedness tests the two levels for each variable are set so as not to be greatly different. For such situations, the calculated effect for any given variable is generally not greatly affected by changes in the level of any of the other variables. A detailed example involving glass electrode measurements of the pH of dilute acid solutions is used to illustrate ruggedness test procedures. A method is presented for evaluating the experimental uncertainties.

1.3 The information in this guide is arranged as follows:

Section
Scope1
Referenced Documents2
Terminology3
Summary of Guide4
Significance and Use5
Plackett-Burman Designs Applied to Ruggedness Tests6
Plackett-Burman Design Calculations7
Plackett-Burman Design Considerations8
Interpretation of Results9
Example10
Testing Effects from Repeated (pH) Experiments11
Controllable versus Uncontrollable Factors12
Additional Information13
Tables
Figures
Appendixes
Additional Plackett-Burman

Appendix X1.

DesignsShort-Cut CalculationsReferences

X1.3.

1.4 This standard does not purport to address all of the safety concerns, if any, associated with its use. It is the responsibility of the user of this standard to establish appropriate safety and health practices and determine the applicability of regulatory limitations prior to use.

 
2. Referenced Documents

E456-13a(2022)

Standard Terminology Relating to Quality and Statistics (Includes all amendments and changes 4/21/2022).

F2082-15

Standard Test Method for Determination of Transformation Temperature of Nickel-Titanium Shape Memory Alloys by Bend and Free Recovery

E1325-21

Standard Terminology Relating to Design of Experiments

E1488-23

Standard Guide for Statistical Procedures to Use in Developing and Applying Test Methods